The right choice depends on the doorway, not the brochure
When an organisation decides to move to biometric attendance, the first question is often: which technology is best? The useful question is a different one: where will the terminal go, who will use it, and in what conditions?
A single site can have a clean, quiet reception area, a workshop where dust settles on everything, and a staff entrance where everyone arrives within the same fifteen minutes. One method imposed everywhere will end up causing trouble somewhere.
The four methods, plainly
Fingerprint
The most widespread and best understood. Staff place a finger on a reader and are recognised. Enrolment is simple and the hardware is common.
Its limits are well known: fingers worn by manual work, very dry skin, cuts, dust on the sensor or on hands. The simplest remedy is to register several fingers per person. And everyone touches the same surface, which raises a hygiene question.
Palm
The terminal reads the palm, a much larger surface than a fingertip. This can help for staff whose fingerprints read poorly. As with any method, try it on site with a handful of your own staff before rolling it out.
Face
Facial recognition is contactless. It suits places where hygiene matters, where hands are dirty or gloved, and dusty workshops. It does, however, need careful placement: no backlight from a door open onto the yard, no direct sunlight on the screen, a sensible height.
Badge
An RFID card is not biometric. It is there for posts where biometrics are not practical. Its weakness is obvious: a badge can be lent. It proves a card went past the reader, not that a particular person was there. Keep it for cases that justify it, ideally within sight of a supervisor.
Four criteria for deciding
Dust and the state of people's hands
A dusty workshop cannot run on fingerprints: it will be face or badge. The same goes for jobs where hands are always wet, oily or gloved.
Rush hour
The morning problem is not the technology, it is the queue. If all staff arrive at once, what matters is the number of terminals per entrance and how smoothly each person gets through. One colleague whose fingerprint fails on the third attempt holds up everyone behind them. Count your peak-hour flow before deciding how many devices you need.
Hygiene
In a health centre, a kitchen or a laboratory, a surface touched by every member of staff several times a day is a problem. Contactless face recognition is the natural answer.
Cost
The price of the terminal is only part of the bill. Add installation, cabling, an uninterruptible power supply at each entry point where the mains is unreliable, and maintenance. Across several buildings, trips to add a new starter or check a faulty device soon add up. A cheap terminal that half the workforce cannot use ends up costing more than a suitable one.
Combining methods
Nothing forces you to choose a single method for the whole organisation. Very often the right answer is a mix:
- fingerprint in the offices;
- face in workshops and hygiene-sensitive areas;
- badge for the few posts where nothing else works.
Two conditions keep that mix simple. First, the same person must be able to enrol on several methods, so they can use their face when their fingerprint lets them down, or clock in at a door other than their usual one. Second, every clock-in must land in the same register; otherwise you are back to reconciling spreadsheets by hand at the end of the month.
That is how OPTimes, our attendance and payroll platform, works: staff can be enrolled on fingerprint, palm, face and badge at once, and every clock-in feeds the same register and, from there, the payroll calculation.
Before you buy: walk the site
A floor plan never tells you where the light is awkward or where a wall is too thick to run a cable through. Before ordering:
- Count the real entry points, including the unofficial ones.
- Watch the morning rush, stopwatch in hand.
- Check the light at each spot, morning and afternoon.
- Check the power supply and plan for a UPS.
- Test with a small group, including staff whose hands do heavy work.
- Decide who will enrol new starters, and train them.
The right terminal is the one every member of staff can use on the first Monday morning, not the one with the most impressive spec sheet.
We carry out this site visit before any quote. If you are planning an installation, tell us about your sites.